Wednesday 26 June 2013

Give unto Caesar what is his.

What now for the larger than life former Prime Minister of Italy. After a terrible verdict on his sex party life style Silvio Berlusconi was found guilty of paying for sex with an under-age prostitute. Despite both her and his protestations that no sex ever took place he was sentenced to 7 years imprisonment and barred from public office for life. He was also found guilty of abusing the powers of his office by arranging for the police to set free the girl whilst she was under arrest. Many witnesses at the trial have been referred by the judge for possible perjury.{see HG}

So, that's the end of him.

Well, we doubt it. Silvio has survived worse than this. And the judgement is a lower court judgement. It can be successfully appealed almost indefinitely. And he is holding up one of the most rickety coalitions ever assembled in an Italian parliament. No one wants him to go today if it means elections tomorrow. Go later Silvio. In a few years time.

Much more serious for Berlusconi is the charge of tax evasion. Found guilty last year he was given a four {reduced to one} year jail sentence. Mr Berlusconi is on his last appeal.
He was also convicted of wire-tapping. In a case that makes Watergate look mild he was accused of having police who were tapping an opponents phone, release the tapes to the media. He was sentenced to a year in jail and his usual barring from public office.

And these are just the latest. The serious ones that involved Tessa Jowell's former {former? Wiki} } husband David Mills, over loans, bribes and perjury have expired under the statute of limitations.

Mr Berlusconi, as always, declares himself to be a victim of left wing forces seeking to discredit him. its a conspiracy.

***

When Julius Caesar wanted to come back to Rome in triumph after the Gallic Wars he had a problem. He had exceeded his authority.
 Well, a bit more than that. He had raised armies without sanction. Declared war without instruction. Invaded foreign lands. Crossed the Rhine to attack the barbarians in Germany, nowhere near his official province which was just across the Alps.  He declared war on tribe after Gallic tribe. Bribed other tribes with the loot stolen from the first. Captured so many slaves he depressed the market. Invaded Britain. Attacked Roman 'friend and ally' chieftains, caused the formerly warring tribes of Gaul to unite in a war against Rome and waged a ruthless, genocidal war of astonishing military brilliance that made him famous, adored, feared, loved, despised and supremely rich.

He had run up debts that he could never have paid in a 100 lifetimes on his climb to the high offices of Rome. The governorship of Gaul was his way to conquer and pillage back that colossal sum of money he owed. He had bribed and bought senators, Tribunes and Consuls to get to the ultimate top place. First man in Rome. At the end of his 10 years as governor he wanted to go home.

The senate refused. Caesar must disband his illegal armies, give up his offices { which gave him immunity from prosecution} and return to Rome to face trial.
The Senate wasn't offering much to Julius . A trial with disgrace, loss of titles, loss of assets, loss of status and exile or death. And they were a bit foolish to threaten a man who's exploits had been read with excitement daily in the Forum for decades. And a man with 10 seasoned, battle-hardened legions, populated by soldiers who's entire fortunes and futures depended solely on their commander, when they had none of their own.

Caesar, ever the charmer and diplomat schemer made numerous offers and suggestions. He didn't really want a  great Triumph or the accolades of the Senate. He didn't want to retain his armies as his own private fighting force as other had previously. He just wanted to be allowed to escape prosecution for his many crimes.
 And he could spin it well. Hadn't he expanded the Republic like never before? Secured the troublesome northern frontier for ever. Seen off the wild northern savages? Brought wagon after wagon of riches to the capital for all to share? He'd brought order from chaos and all for the benefit of the Senate. Wasn't he the richest man in the world?  If they could just see to forgetting about how he came to be where he was now and just .. enjoy the fruits of it all, then everyone would be winners. There was enough land, slaves and gold for all.

After the senate rejected all of Caesar's demands and compromises, including a standing down of all armies by everyone, he decided on war. He marched on Rome, won, was declared Dictator and ended the Roman Republic for ever.

So..Silvio?
If his options become narrower and his prospects slimmer might he decide that the time for dealing is over? Why not go straight to the mob? The Italian people have already experienced 'nearly change' only recently. He could offer 'actual change'.  Become a populist rabble rousing politician, speaking directly to the masses without fear of consequences. Offering the unthinkable. An end to Parliaments. A new constitution. New people's assemblies. A new Lira. A cancellation of all domestic debts. A new start. New homes taken from the elites. Palaces turned into Hospitals and schools. No more taxes for the young or old.
It would be child's play for him to bring down the current government.  And by making deals with the Grillo's and assorted anarchy factions , deals they could accept because Silvio would no longer be trying to maintain the status quo, but to break it, he could light a fire.

Might it not just be better for the Italian government and judiciary to let the appeals drag on?
Like Caesar he doesn't want to bring down the very structures he has spent so long and so much on climbing up. But like Caesar, if the alternative is prosecution and banishment.. well then...?


9 comments:

  1. King Ralph6:11 pm

    Silvio - He came, he saw, he concubined.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Or he might end up swinging upside down from a lamp post?

    ReplyDelete
  3. dearieme7:32 pm

    As long as he doesn't invade Abyssinia.

    ReplyDelete
  4. dearieme7:33 pm

    Or, more seriously: who would be prepared to die to defend Italian democracy when the EU has already abolished it?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wonderfully illustrated.

    The collateral damage in all this is extensive and horrid. What kind of person, what kind of political view, thinks it a good plan to brand a 17 year old (without residence or residency) a whore so as to entrap a politician they are unable to defeat at the ballot box? Indeed brand a whole group of young people whores - that's not even a category I recognise.

    And for the Prosecutor to stand in the court room and say (of Karima el-Mahroug) "She displayed oriental cunning" is to remove us back in time 60 years (or to Sax Rohmer).

    The Italian judiciary lacks utterly the humanity of an English judge. As Lord Denning noted "She was only 21..."

    ReplyDelete
  6. ""Much more serious for Berlusconi is the charge of tax evasion. Found guilty last year he was given a four {reduced to one} year jail sentence. Mr Berlusconi is on his last appeal.
    He was also convicted of wire-tapping. In a case that makes Watergate look mild he was accused of having police who were tapping an opponents phone, release the tapes to the media. He was sentenced to a year in jail and his usual barring from public office.""

    ReplyDelete
  7. perfect "" Well, we doubt it. Silvio has survived worse than this. And the judgement is a lower court judgement. It can be successfully appealed almost indefinitely. And he is holding up one of the most rickety coalitions ever assembled in an Italian parliament. No one wants him to go today if it means elections tomorrow. Go later Silvio. In a few years time.

    ""

    ReplyDelete
  8. interesting this is one of the great and very interesting articles that i read .......... i find it useful and perfect because it can solve so many issues that happen to us...... when i read it i get the message and i know the key way that will provide me with good solution ..... so thanks so much for this article is very great ...... and very interesting ..... to share it with us is like a honor from you ........thanks a lot ...

    ReplyDelete
  9. right ........ so this topic is fantastic """ What now for the larger than life former Prime Minister of Italy. After a terrible verdict on his sex party life style Silvio Berlusconi was found guilty of paying for sex with an under-age prostitute. Despite both her and his protestations that no sex ever took place he was sentenced to 7 years imprisonment and barred from public office for life. He was also found guilty of abusing the powers of his office by arranging for the police to set free the girl whilst she was under arrest. Many witnesses at the trial have been referred by the judge for possible perjury.{see HG}""

    ReplyDelete