Friday, 20 November 2026

Milburn's NEETS fantasy-plan (2)

 Further to the preceding post, & having staked out my positions that:

  1. Underlying the NEETS issue (to use the shorthand) is something deeply unsatisfactory in the UK today, which IF it can be rectified, we'd all be the better for;
  2. Loss / erosion of agency, for an individual and for a social grouping, has baleful consequences.
... so, onwards to Milburn's 'solutions'.  Something he's been too polite to say is that Reeves' wretched Budget did a lot of damage via the NI changes.  Well, this is politics, right.  Let's recap a couple of things that have been said during the week.

Institutional persistence:  Milburn's plan has it that everything is to be individually tailored.  If, after all that has been offered[1], an individual "disengages" with the process (and presumably returns to NEET-dom rather than finds their own way forward), individually-tailored efforts must be made to reengage them - more (and presumably 'better') offers, more coaching & counselling etc etc - before sanctions "which should be rare" are applied[2].  Sounds very humane, no?  Indeed, almost like the Church ministering to a recidivist sinner[3]. 

Personal responsibilities:  "None of this is to argue that young people do not have personal responsibility to make the best of things. Effort matters. Attendance matters. Behaviour matters. Young people have agency and obligations... 

The deal will only work if the young person co-develops the Plan and is a co-signatory to it. Responsibilities have to sit alongside entitlements. That should take 3 forms: be available for an agreed form of participation where able; make and pursue a Participation Plan; and do not refuse reasonable offers[1] without good cause. These 3 obligations should be enshrined in a new duty to engage which young people receiving benefits should agree as part of their personalised Participation Plan."  

Hmm.  All sounds right - and very Blairite, of course.  But remember: these days, schools must get parents to 'co-sign' schooling 'agreements' before the child starts, with all manner of reasonable, basic undertakings - that are routinely flouted by many thereafter.  Is it more than just a neat institutional trick, enabling Authority to wash their hands of it?      

Here's where all this personalised intervention breaks down.

Practical level: sheer complexity

When I was in the Army, some new-broom CO rocked up and declared he saw a massive skills / training deficit (we weren't all sufficiently capable of doing everything - daft, in a unit where almost everyone was a specialist for which literally years of training was required).  So he had some hapless staff officer draw up a plan to correct our shortcomings.  What he came up with was a system of "cascading instruction" where everyone trained others in their speciality, and in turn received training in some alien discipline from a practitioner in that.  There was a diagram of how all this worked, and it looked OK on a whiteboard - at first glance.  That was until you worked out for each training interaction the time taken for all concerned - just the delivery time, let alone prep.  Simple arithmetic thereafter was sufficient to demonstrate that, like a Ponzi scheme, it couldn't work.  

And thus for Milburn's plan.  Intuitively, it can't possibly be delivered on the individuated basis he's describing.  It either breaks down immediately under the strain of heroic efforts to make the impossible work; or 'personalised' is never implemented as described, and eventually everyone involved just becomes embittered and disillusioned.  The costs will be considerable, either way: and some smart consultancies etc will coin it (see 'Agency' below).

Look at the NHS, which reckons to deliver personalised service - "nothing about me without me", etc - but how often is this true?  In the real world, completely personalised medical attention is granted only to the Monarch (and just maybe to some very high-rolling individuals).  Everyone else gets mass-delivery "cure du jour", more or less.  And that's not wrong!   A national health set-up can very frequently improve health en masse, when it gets things right and delivers it effectively - which it sometimes does.  That's what it's for.  But that's a statistical appraisal. "Take statins / paracetamol etc" - the stats are impressive.  Personalised?  If you're lucky - but absolutely no guarantees or genuine institutional commitment.  Line up and the nurse will administer your jab in turn. X% of you will turn out to be allergic to it.  Well, there you go ... (see paracetamol above).

Conceptual level: personal agency

This brings us to yesterday's discussion.  In contrast with the iron logic of over-complexity, I accept it has a philosophical / doctrinal flavour, and one can't be quite so definitive in one's critique.  But saying "Young people have agency ...", as Milburn does, is altogether too glib.  Incidentally, that's the only reference to 'agency' in this sense in the entire doc.  'Agency' with a capital 'A' appears many times, of course.  Oh, yes!  (All with CEOs on fat salaries, yeah, we know.)

I will leave it at this:  my intuition is that in many cases, "opportunities served up" in the manner anticipated - and still more in the manner I anticipate (given the above-mentioned complexities) - won't play to individual agency, they will by-pass it completely and probably erode it further.  This doesn't make for a enduring solution.

Oh dear - all very cynical & defeatist: where's your answer, smartarse?  Well - not for today.  

Have a good weekend!

ND

________________

[1] 'Reasonable' offers: who can object to reasonableness?  But - what does it mean?  The civil service draftsmen know.  When I was Chair of Housing in a big borough, that was the test we were under when making offers of accommodation to the 'homeless' (another term in need of careful unpacking - but not now).  In practice, it meant "enough bedrooms, according to government guidelines, plus power, heating & running water.  Of course, the 'homeless' had other criteria in mind: "next door to Mum", "on the ground floor", "a house with a garden, not a flat", "not on an estate", "near such-and-such school", "no condensation on the walls",  etc.  But we had a waiting list queuing right round the block and out of sight.  Our having ensured we met the reasonableness test, it all boiled down to: accept the offer, or you're off the list.  Much wailing and gnashing of teeth.  But what else could we do?  Make three reasonable offers?  Four?

[2] That full account of how saintly-patient, forgiving, iterative and of course personalised the pre-sanctions redemption process will be, doesn't appear quite like that in the written report.  But it's how Milburn elaborated it verbally.

[3] Like so much British 'socialism', it bears a strong resemblance to a secular kind of Christianity, (though not of the sterner Protestant variety).  It's not a coincidence.  Curiously, a lot of them are resistant to acknowledging it.

On this subject, and harking back to my 'ex villager' of yesterday: he said there used to be a hymn in his region, the words of which included "God hates lazy people" ...

17 comments:

dearieme said...

Your "new-broom CO": I have a memory that during The War wireless operators for Lancasters and the like were given a little navigational training - presumably enough so that they'd have a decent chance of bringing the plane home if the navigator was killed.

But my memory is not good so I may be wrong on that.

Nick Drew said...

Sounds very prudent, & a good model. They could possibly also press the trigger on a tail-gun. But I guess they weren't trained to be reserve pilots as well? That would be the analogy here.

On the subject of navigation: my knowledge of the Navy is limited, but I understand it used to be the case that every RN officer was trained to navigate by the sun and stars - so that they could take their turn as Officer of the Watch. Could they all do that today? (Just in case "someone" pulled the plug on GPS satellites, e.g.)

Anonymous said...

Agency == Personal Responsibility (like Woke == Political Correctness).
Long since gone from these shores. Everything is now someone else's fault.

Nick Drew said...

Indeed, anon

The neat thing about using the word 'agency' is that like 'freedom', nobody can be against it, and even wokists / lefties[1] consider it a positive attribute (nominally). If you tell someone "Take responsibility (you idle sod)", there's a ready verbal response - "the State should be responsible[2] for that".

Granted, the left does have a response, even to advocacy of individual agency: "Exercise your agency - you do have agency, don't you? (you idle sod)". The new line is "yes, but he needs 'support'". (generally = cash in hand with no strings attached)
________________________
[1] Marxists will tell you that despite agency being a grand thing, under capitalism the workers don't have any, and that any belief on their part that they do is "false consciousness" & a subtle deception on behalf of the interests to the ruling class. But at least 'agency' features as a positive in the account.

[2] Anecdote: when I was first an expectant father we went to the ante natal clinic, to be told: "we are the maternity department and we are responsible for your baby until the age of one". Obviously I told them otherwise, and was looked at as if I was an anarchist or lunatic. And that was a good few years ago.

decnine said...

So, in addition to the National Care Service, Burnham announces the National Kiss It Better Service. Those who don't want to be Kissed Better by the Government will be taught that if the Government wants to Kiss Them Better, they will effing well get Kissed and pretend to like it. Will Russell Brand be released to chair the relevant quango?

jim said...

What problem is Milburn trying to solve here. Is it an ongoing lack of good employment opportunities, or a lack of the right sort of education provision or some sort of barrier to 'apprenticeships'. Or is it that he faces a burgeoning welfare bill he can't afford.

Looks to me Milburn has an utterly hopeless task. His only hope is to kick the can down the road and waste time and money of some long drawn out 'review'. As is well known the consulting firms absolutely love 'a review'. Lots of study time, lots of chin stroking and scribbling and absolutely nothing useful at the end. Bona - Milburn escapes responsibility.

Anyone can make anything on a very large scale to more or less perfect design and tolerances anywhere in the world. Just pour a lot of concrete, provide new machinery and new power lines and punch any tiresome objectors in the mouth.

We seem to have plenty of archivists and archaeologists and sociologists and campaigners of every stripe. Ideal for running a luxury museum industry but not much else.

What Britain and Europe needs is a nice war and lose. Plenty of not so creative destruction. Alas and alack, no one can afford old style war any more, all too interconnected. So the Milburns of our world will have to handle managed decline or try and create jobs for people no one wants or has a use for.

A bit annoying for those folk deluded into thinking the lower orders are lazy toerags. But taxation for benefits is the quid pro quo of running an unbalanced economy.

BlokeInBrum said...

I don't know about the R.N. but I did read this article about the US Navy recently. It seems they want to keep their hand in with celestial navigation 'just in case'.

https://www.navigation-mac.fr/lu-s-navy-de-retour-au-sextant/?lang=en

Anonymous said...

I'd argue agency and personal responsibility are related, but distinct, concepts:

Agency - could I
Moral/Ethic - should I
Personal responsibility - would I

CH

Anonymous said...

One counter I'd have for Millburn is that government has agency too, however that agency is heavily moderated - backbenchers, civil servants, courts...

So it isn't just about agency, but also what frustrates it. But that might involve conversations that would cause many backbenchers to cough up their skulls.

CH

Nick Drew said...

@ Jim - Is it an ongoing lack of good employment opportunities, or a lack of the right sort of education provision or some sort of barrier to 'apprenticeships'. Or is it that he faces a burgeoning welfare bill he can't afford. Looks to me Milburn has an utterly hopeless task.

Agreed. Something I didn't find space for in the (already lengthy) posts was this exchange: I paraphrase.
Interviewer: But take Blackpool, the NEETs capital of the UK - there are no jobs!
Burnham: So look at who are the big employers in Blackpool - it's the NHS and the Council. Public bodies need to step up, too.

So what can this mean? Only that the said bodies will be told: take an extra 100 people on the payroll - just get on with it.

Now that is exactly how the USSR operated its Jobs For All philosophy, with the concomitant sullen "they pretend to employ us, we pretend to work" mentality. It didn't end well.

Closer to home: just across the Channel, when EDF and GDF were vast public monopolies, they were given the same kind of instructions by the French govt. They made a slightly - but only slightly - better job of it, with semi-technical apprenticeships. And of course it took the cost off the taxpayer and dumped it onto the energy bill payer - not quite the same population, and less visible in the public accounts: exactly the trick UK politicians have used for "renewables" subsidies etc.

Milburn: where are these hapless Blackpool public bodies going to get the money?

dearieme said...

The NHS? What a good idea. They could open a new anti-natal clinic, as midwifery services are called nowadays.

Clive said...

Same in France. Election coming up? Unemployment high? No problem! Mitterrand

Clive said...

(… continued after butter fingers clicked on the button) would just ask SNCF or the French postal service to go out and hire 100,000 new staff.

Worked a treat as a short-term fix, but not a long-term answer obviously. And the real costs are still being paid, in the form of those generous public sector pensions…

Clive said...

This all sounds to me like it’s not evolved the debate beyond the “deserving poor / undeserving poor” dilemma.

It’s attempting to devise a technocratic process to try to answer that question, but that’s inevitably going to let some of the deserving poor continue to receive benefits and other state support (the administration costs of all this sound exorbitant) while some undeserving poor get stuck in the pretty, intrusive and often incompetent bureaucracy.

Anonymous said...

Don't forget that some of this bureaucracy will also be corrupt, which was a problem in local government even when the UK was pretty monocultural. Now it'll be several times worse - see the NHS entrepreneurs during covid selling jab certificates for hard cash.

Anonymous said...

Seems to me there’s an opening here for some cutting edge ( read expensive) consultancy to offer an AI based individualised program to train/encourage/find job opportunities/ generally hand hold, plus returning a compliance score, with extra remuneration for those showing effort. Of course it would be open to hacking/gaming the system; thenAI would have to evolve to keep it more work to crack than actually doing something useful. (As an aside, I have always thought that the Mensa intelligence test did not need to be ultra hard to cheat, just to the point where if you were clever enough to beat it then you could pass anyway.)

dearieme said...

The National Kiss It Better Service: applause!