Wednesday, 18 November 2026

NEETS, Milburn - and a new socialistic fantasy (part 1)

Let's record an axiomatic starting-point: at the level of individuals, there are few things more dispiriting than to see someone who's given up on participation in purposeful human existence.  Which, for the overwhelming majority "of working age", should at least include working and earning to contribute (in most circumstances, to contribute fully) to earning one's keep, as part of an enterprise where human contact is integral to the arrangement.  

Lack of a basic level of agency diminishes and demoralises a human being, a point I shall return to.  Lack of meaning in life destroys humanity - and we know who stands ready to fill a meaninglessness-vacuum.

In practical terms. plainly, it's bloody difficult for many people of lower-than-average initiative and personal drive, to "find work" when there are no conventionally-advertised jobs in their locale.  The numbers that will ditch local ties and simply head for the metropolis are relatively few, outside of the better-educated (where it may be the norm).  Still fewer are the born entrepreneurs for whom Richard Branson is a role model.  Rather more will gravitate towards the grey / black / outright criminal economies.  This leaves a significant mass of what we must nowadays term NEETS, whose inactivity and often complete lethargy isn't doing anyone any good whatsoever.  (The days when capitalists could secretly welcome a 'reserve army of unemployed' are over:  these days, outright profit-seekers that need low-skilled human labour in their enterprise go for subsistence-waged foreigners, either imported or kept offshore.) 

Given where we are now, it's therefore not difficult to recognise where at least one of the drivers of Milburn's mandate comes from.  The altruistic one, that is: because reducing the welfare bill seems also to be out there as an end in its own right, even within Burnham's Cabinet.  In Part 2 we'll come back to Milburn's plan which - spoiler alert - seems to me wildly impracticable, and almost certainly doomed to fail.  But before that, I want to lay down another input to my own thoughts on the subject, which centre around Agency in practical "working age" human life.

A couple of weeks ago I had a long sit-down with a distinguished member of the 'global majority' who works, in both academic and practical arenas - on the issue of agency.  He has assembled a large body of case studies of individuals and social groupings that have demonstrated remarkable degrees of highly purposeful agency, often in the most unlikely circumstances, including conditions of extreme adversity.  (Note for the really cynical: he is not cataloguing third-world kleptocrats, purposeful though they may be.)

Recently he returned to his own village.  He characterised the surroundings he grew up in as being self-reliant and purposeful to a high degree, including outright entrepreneurial activity and trading with many other communities, near and far.  To his surprise, upon returning he found indolence and lethargy.  When he asked someone he felt was well-placed to be actively grasping any number of opportunities that seemed obviously present, he was told: "we don't have good enough road access".  To which our man replied: I have just come 50 miles in a taxi, on a perfectly serviceable road: what are you talking about?  Oh, said his interlocutor, "about a km out of town there's a stretch that is badly potholed for several hundred metres".  So what are you doing about it?   "We're waiting for the Bill Gates foundation to fix it - an NGO has made a funding application for us".

On his own account, our man was at once angry and utterly dismayed.  (He looked into the NGO and found its CEO is being paid more than the US Treasury Secretary.)

I think you can see where I'm going with this: but more in Part 2.

ND

No comments: