Thursday, 11 June 2009

North West Hutton: An Old Oilman's Story

Draw up a sandbag and swing the lamp …

The other day I noticed an article announcing that the largest offshore oil platform ever to be dismantled - North West Hutton, from the North Sea – had finally been brought to shore for scrap. This has indeed been a technical triumph – but not necessarily for the reasons BP would have you believe ...

* * * * * * *
North West Hutton was discovered in 1975 by Amoco, 130 km north east of Shetland in 143 m of water. It was indisputably a huge find, set to rival its neighbour, the mighty Brent: but its geology was complex: “a series of tilted fault blocks and extreme lateral and vertical heterogeneity”, i.e a large number of small, hard-to-access segments or, in the words of the senior Amoco geologist, “a tub of guts”.

But engineers love building things: so the owners went ahead and built a huge 39,000 tonne platform, which went into production in 1983. However, even after 55 wells were drilled, the worst fears were realised and the field would not yield its oil. Production should have been 130,000 barrels per day: it peaked momentarily at 86,000 and fell back to 20,000 – a technical and economic disaster, made worse by the oil price collapse of 1986.

A disaster of another kind happened at Piper Alpha in 1988, and the Cullen Enquiry recommended that expensive safety modifications be made to offshore installations. By its tenth birthday, the financial status of North West Hutton was distinctly sub-economic - a candidate for early decommissioning.

But abandoning North Sea platforms comes at a huge capital cost: so every day’s delay in recognising the inevitable is money in the bank. And every small thing that can be done to eke out its life is an effort well spent.

Amoco set to with a will. An new Offshore Installation Manager (OIM) was appointed; a feisty Welshman, the kind of engineer who sees things in black and white. If a widget is strictly needed, it stays: if it isn’t, it goes. He started stripping things off the platform on a very large scale – and as with so many engineering projects, there was plenty of gold-plating to sacrifice. And with every widget that goes overboard, another widget – whose only purpose was to monitor the first one, goes too. Soon, he’d stripped the platform down to the bare essentials – and that was pretty damned bare – slashing operating costs and buying several years of delay.

Ten years on, with BP now in charge and oil prices even lower, the inevitable seemed at last to be nigh: so a complex decommissioning scheme was devised (no hurry, chaps!) ‘Production’ – by now a derisory trickle - ceased in 2002: the scheme was approved in 2006 … and in 2009 it’s all over.

Funny business, economics. Happy days !

ND

10 comments:

roym said...

sorry if i missed something, but is there oil still down there?
if so i'd love to see how one would take on the technical challenge

Nick Drew said...

yes roy, there must be pretty substantial quantities left in the ground - even more than usual (50% recovery of oil-in-place often counts as very good indeed)

you may be 100% sure the best minds in the oil bizz have been bent to the problem, before they finally gave up

so - seems to be beyond current technology. But it ain't going anywhere !

Demetrius said...

It would have made a lovely block of flats somewhere, say between Port Glasgow and Gorbals.

Blue Eyes said...

Ain't the free market great!

Anonymous said...

It's Friday, 10.06 UK time, and Robert Peston has disappeared from the front page of BBC Business News. No links to his blog or stories at all.

Has there been a BBC coup ?

Erin cody said...

This blog is an exact representation of skills. I appreciate the blogger for posting the most excellent thought. This topic posted by you is trustworthy. 
www.ccsvi-mri.co.uk |

Emma Hardy said...

This is truly good content and informative weblog, I praise what youve done here, along with sharing great material with excellent suggestions and concepts, Im truly pleased to post my comment on this weblog, many thank yous to the author.
leadcubetechnologies.com |

Abigail Alexandra said...

It was a positive conversation and each day since then he has made an effort to come and speak to her about his success of the day. 
www.rsnewhomes.com |

nimi parker said...

Izrada web stranica koje ce Vam dovesti nove klijente. Prepustite brigu o Vašoj web stranici profesionalcima
fitnessorange.com |

nimi parker said...

Izrada web stranica koje ce Vam dovesti nove klijente. Prepustite brigu o Vašoj web stranici profesionalcima
fitnessorange.com |